We get the books we deserve
Guardian Unlimited: Arts blog - books: Britain does not publish enough gay fiction
Gay books with the potential to sell to a mainstream audience are the only ones UK publishers seem interested in. We could and should do a lot better.
Two of the comments on this post included: ‘As a practising Geordie, I am always concerned about the lack of representation of Geordies in literature…’ and ‘For my own part, I’m deeply concerned about the over-representation of the Irish in contemporary fiction…’.
Now, from what I can tell being gay or writing about gay characters is not going to stop you being published nor is writing about being Irish, Scottish, Pink, Purple or being a clown. What is going to stop you is how attractive your writing is to a wider audience unless you are being published by a specialist/niche press.
Horror writing seems to be a niche, unless you’re Stephen King, who manages to cross from a niche market to the mainstream. Fantasy is more popular than Sci-Fi luckily both Fantasy and Sci-Fi have a wide and established fan base so you can’t really call them niche.
Poppy Z. Brite started her career writing about gay characters. Sarah Waters writes exclusively about them, and she is well received and rewarded. Alan Hollinghurst’s award winning Line of Beauty was converted into a BBC Drama and based around the life of a gay Conservative.
There is a whole list that I made on the above blog post of recent titles that don’t seem to support the argument.
I wonder if you can say that Black/Asian literature is niche with characters like Monica Ali, Zadie Smith, and Murakami Haruk being in the mainstream?
Does everyone need a writer who writes about them? And how can we support those writers who write about what might be considered under-represented?
Another question is from all this is how much of what you read should be about identifying with what you are reading and how much should be about escaping from it?
